QUESTIONS? Text our office at (317) 934-3613

Circle City Realty
Circle City Realty
  • Sign In
  • Create Account

  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • My Account
  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • FOR RENT
  • Meet The Team
  • FAQ's
  • APPLY
  • Why Invest in RE?
  • Resident Portal Access
  • Owner Portal Access
  • Resident Toolkit
  • Resident Referral Program

Account


  • My Account
  • Sign out


  • Sign In
  • My Account

Meet The Circle City Realty Team

Professional woman smiling confidently in a gray blazer against a plain background.

Kaylee Cawthorne

Managing Broker, REALTOR®, Senior Property Manager

E-mail: Kaylee@CircleCityRealty.com

Cell: (317) 797-5610


Managing Broker Kaylee Cawthorne has served Circle City Realty since 2012, overseeing brokerage and property management operations. Her industry experience and local knowledge help clients make informed real estate decisions across Indiana.

Young woman in a black blazer smiling confidently indoors.

Kalista Foster

Associate Broker, Project Manager

Email: Kalista@CircleCityRealty.com

Cell: (317) 902-0383


  Kalista serves as a field specialist and project manager with Circle City Realty. She performs property inspections, assists with leasing, and ensures structural quality and integrity of our clients' investments. As a licensed Real Estate broker, Kalista is passionate about expanding her expertise to help educate, facilitate and assist renters with their goals of becoming homeowners. Outside of real estate, she enjoys cozy nights in watching movies, crafting, or gaming. 

Dena Johnston

Assistant Property Manager

Email: Dena@CircleCityRealty.com

Cell: (317) 690-9320


 Dena serves as the Assistant Property Manager for Circle City Realty, where she helps oversee daily operations, tenant communications and maintenance requests. Known for her prompt problem-solving and welcoming demeanor, Dena excels at bridging the gap between residents and maintenance teams to ensure a high-quality living environment. When she isn’t helping residents feel at home, Dena enjoys spending time with her four children and her five grandchildren.   

Rachael Harrison

Owner, Tally Up Bookkeeping

Email: Accounting@CircleCityRealty.com

www.tallyupbookkeeping.biz

Follow us on Instagram!

Follow me on Instagram

Connect With Us

Copyright © 2026 Circle City Realty - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept